Saturday, August 18, 2018

The Tale of the Swale



What exactly is a "swale"? Well, you can think of it as both a drainage conduit, and a stormwater absorption zone. This man-made land feature must be maintained and kept open in order to function as intended. Taylor Morrison and Waldrop Engineering are currently designing such a swale system to run nearly the entire length (over 6000 feet) between the land of SEBPOG homes and the newly - to be elevated - land of the proposed project. Gated access points will be provided at various points along its length so that workers can enter the "swale trail" (pathway - if you will), to cut, and maintain it.

At this point, SEBPOG doesn't know exactly how deep the swale will be (info. may be forthcoming), nor how wide the trail beside it will be... some swales are "cut-able" by large lawn mowers, and others are steep and can only be maintained by crews with weed wackers - often moving down the swales with small trail vehicles.  However, whatever will be "back there" - there'll be a definitive "path" of sorts, that never existed before... It must always be remembered and respected, that many SEBPOG property owners, purchased these particular border parcels in Sorrento East because they wanted privacy in their backyards - a privacy that is now in jeopardy.


While our requested wall, will hopefully prevent unwanted human incursions and visitors from the east, currently there is no such planned barrier from the edge of our properties to the swale (unless we erect one ourselves - on our back fence lines). This "compromise" of an unfenced TM border was suggested by SEBPOG & TM; i.e. -  no barbwire type fence or barrier directly on their property line, in the hope that long time encroaching SE property owners might still retain some usage of their unowned land (up to the wall) - as several have had possession of it for up to the past 20 years. That can be good, or bad...

Additionally, the swale may closely follow the proposed berm (with wall atop) or they may be separated some distance apart. If you have wetlands directly beyond your perimeter, the swale would most likely travel out around the wetlands to the East.  However, in all cases, you (and others) would either have direct access to the swale system and up to the wall, or access to the swale through (or around) the seasonal wetlands and up to the wall  - again, unless a barrier is erected. In actuality, the swale will essentially tie all the SEBPOG properties together via a commonly accessible backyard pathway.


While we can appreciate its convenience for "frog hunting" young boys or friendly neighbors - to desire a private "back door" conduit between homes;  it also opens the possibilities for those with more sinister intentions to potentially gain unauthorized access to the back of SEBPOG homes from perhaps quite  a distance down the street. This is a new security concern, that previously didn't exist.

Let's look at a hypothetical example:
We could park our "get away" car say 10 houses south of our target dwelling - down on the street on the side of the road between two sleepy homes who's occupants appear to be  "Up North" for the season... Walking due east from the road then, we boldly go between the two houses - and quickly disappear into the swale trail system. Then its just a private stroll north ten homes to the one we want...  A quick dash west across their back lawn to the rear sliders... and out comes the crowbar.  Pop. We're in!  We'll do the exact reverse - once we have their pillowcases filled with goodies for quick sale on Craig's List.
So, if we take the above seriously... and unfortunately - we should; this presents a bit of a conundrum. We want the wall to protect our property values, isolate us from the noise and dirt of the jobsite, and to keep unwanted and unknown people out from the east... and it will do that (hopefully).  And... we want something decent to look at... to maintain some access to a portion of this property we have previously enjoyed;  but now, the swale opens up this new insecurity  - in our backyards from the east.  We will have to choose between having no back fence, greater insecurity, a perceived bigger backyard with access up to the wall or wetlands (near or far as it is designed), or - building our own fence or wall on our back property lines to secure unwanted entry and or observation.
If you have pets, and want to keep them out of the wetlands or swale/trail, a back fence is going to be a must. Happily, Sorrento East deed restrictions allow, with approval - currently as written - six foot high fences for all properties on the border of SE; and, in the actual wording -  the direct specifying and or limiting which sides of said qualifying properties these six foot fences may be erected on is delightfully missing... As such, legally - you could run it up the sides (as well as across the back - if you like) of any border property.  Indeed, the SEPOA board tried to "close out" this option - during the late Great SE Deed Restrictions War of 2013 (and in doing so, inadvertently acknowledged its existence and validity). Happily - for border property owners: they failed!

 
So, if you're a bit uncomfortable with perhaps unknown workers, mulling around in back of your home, messing with the swale zone... maybe having an impromptu picnic in back of your property, or even other unwelcome or unknown neighbors - taking a casual stroll by your previously completely private backyard, and seeing what's going on with it (and you)... a full 6 foot high fence maybe in order to regain your privacy and security.  You can always add a locking gate to it... so you will retain access and usage of  the swale trail (like everyone else will have).

And additional, yet no less important issue for erecting some sort of at least lower height chain link or farm fence on SEBPOG back property lines involves wildlife incursion events into backyards - which has historically, already been an issue. Animal and reptile density will most probably increase once the swale / wetland corridor becomes the only natural still existing greenbelt between the two neighborhoods. In summer, when the swale is heavy with water - you can bet those creatures are going to move out of the wetland areas to utilize the new waterway and travel around. Could there be more gators, snakes, deer, or wild boars in your backyard's future? It's definitely a greater possibility, moving forward.

Finally, we must consider the specter of liability for the development property owner, and the following new homeowners association of Sorrento at Palmer Ranch. It seems to SEBPOG, that this unfenced swale trail mile long buffer zone creates a bit of an insurance nightmare. Without the entire thing being secured, who will be found negligent and or financially responsible, should some young lad get eaten back there by a crock, or someone just falls, slips into the swale, and drowns... After such an event, There'll be all sorts of cries raised that the buffer is a dangerous place and needs to be secured. Indeed, the more we ponder this, the more we wonder about the actual chance of an "unfenced border promise ever being fulfilled by the new property owner...  Thus, , we predict, the forward looking reality: that the "no barrier border zone" - as envisioned  by the developer probably won't happen  (once they work through the issues, as we have). Indeed, the gravity of this final concern, may nullify - much that is written above.  

We should have better answers to all these concerns once the official site plan is fully flushed out...  Alas, whatever they come up with - living with "Das Swale" is going to become a reality, no current SEBPOG resident signed up for.  

Friday, August 3, 2018

SEBPOG Homes Already Slammed with Decreased Value

If you don't believe your home's monetary value isn't going to be adversely effected by the massive multi-year Taylor Morrison project, directly behind you - think again... In fact, its already happening!

Let's face it, there's not too many buyers that are going to stick around, as soon as they here the words "there's a large housing development going In directly in back of this place..." or even as it is now: "they are going for a rezone, to build a large housing complete in back with +320 homes".  Buyers who are coming down for peace, quiet, and even security... will immediately start to look elsewhere! Hardly no one is a fan of the monotone bulldozer tune: "beep beep, beeeep."

So, where does that leave SEBPOG owners? Well, lets take these options one at a time:
  1.  We can wait it out. Hopefully, they will give us our stinking wall, but we will have to grin and bear it for all those months before it goes in. We will have to put up with the blowing dirt, the dirty roofs, the constant low vibrations from gigantic earth moving equipment, the beeping, yada yada yada... Then hopefully, once the site is elevated, the wall can be built... Ahhh - perhaps then, a little quieter and safer on this side of the wall, and more buyers may be interested in your home as it is better isolated and protected from the madness.

  2.  We can sell out now on the cheap. That's right, we can bail on this whole nightmare before it even gets going - but there's a catch - we have to sell at bargain basement rates. That's great news for multiple house owning landlords, who might want the "back row" of Sorrento East to become an entire string of rental houses... Not so good for the neighbors across the street who can then deal with a never ending series of unknown people coming into the neighborhood for short periods of time, and probably without a lot of care for the greater community. Party time!!!  

 Sounds good, huh? I know, it sucks. And don't think if you're just across the street with a view of the jobsite, you're going to fair much better on the "For Sale" market - you won't. Sure, you're a tier down from those directly on the border, but you're no way safe...

How much can we expect our homes to drop during all this? Some estimators state, around 30%. Ouch... that's a serious number, but it reflects the true and dire nature of the problem, as far as buyers are concerned. We're just not that attractive right now... even if your house is pretty as hell - you're home's got an STD, unless this thing is voted down (unlikely), and or until it's relatively complete (5 years into the future). Hey, does anybody in the neighborhood have a spare "flux-capacitor"?

They're On Their Way...


An excellent highly productive meeting took place at the Bellacina Clubhouse on July 31st between SEBPOG Full Members, and representatives of Taylor Morrison (TM) concerning the proposed new development: Sorrento at Palmer Ranch.  Around six tables, within the comfortable confines of the new TM facility - SEBPOG folks put forth a variety of their concerns and suggestions, and engaged individually in meaningful conversations with various members of the TM team - in a "cooperative learning" style fashion - which seemed to work, exceedingly well. Most SEBPOG.ORG members in attendance came away feeling, they had done what they could, to submit their input.

How much Taylor Morrison and Waldrop Engineering, will be able to accommodate and address SEBPOG's advisements, concerns, and suggestions is anyone's guess... We acknowledge the project is not for SEBPOG; it is not for SEPOA (Sorrento East Property Owners Assoc.); and it's not for the current people of Nokomis... This is private property, a private endeavor, and will ultimately be designed as per Taylor Morrison would like it to be (within the confines of county, state, and national regulations). It's their "baby" and SEBPOG.ORG is certainly highly appreciative to all the members of this TM team, for considering the concerns of residents that will be directly effected the most. It was nice to have input, and we were most delighted with the opportunity to be heard.

In some ways, the meeting felt like a "bon voyage party" or a launch, where one group was embarking on a mission, and the other would be left to wait for it's completion. Indeed, this is very much the case - Waldrop Engineering and Taylor Morrison folks will now be busy at work, designing, crafting, and creating the full details of the project - to be presented to everyone probably some time in late October 2018. I certainly wish them good luck and Godspeed on their journey to bring forth something of value to potential new residents of the area, and compatible with those already living here.   

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

SEBPOG's Special Meeting with Taylor Morrison is Today!

Click above for details...

It is very important that SEBPOG.ORG Full Members (Active and Passive), make every effort to attend this meeting of today. This is probably your last opportunity to give your direct input on how you would like the "Buffer Zone" designed. If you want to build "The Great Wall of Sorrento East" - now is the time to be unified with others in your request.

Friday, July 27, 2018

Dan Lobeck Speaks at SEPOA Special Meeting 7/25


**Updated: 07/27/18 @ 19:25

Dan Lobeck, Esq. recently spoke at the special meeting of SEPOA (Sorrento East Property Owners Assoc.) at 7 PM on the 25th of July. SEBPOG members were there in force to listen to the presentation, concerning a topic SEBPOG members have been involved with for the past eight months. Our understanding was that Mr. Lobeck was only engaged for the session - to brief attendees on options the association may have in pursuing legal action against the new Taylor Morrison project, planned for the Sorrento East abutting land in play.

Mr. Lobeck attempted to bring folks up to speed on the situation - which he himself, seemed rather new to. No new ground was covered, which SEBPOG.ORG has not already examined in depth on our website. Mr. Lobeck explained the current pro-building nature of Sarasota County officials, and the lack of adequate avenues, available to stop or hinder the project, other than showing up in mass in county run hearings on the project. Taylor Morrison representatives were also in attendance, of particular note was Mr. Charlie Bailey, Esq. who answered some concerns raised by the audience and Mr. Lobeck.  Mr. Lobeck and Mr. Bailey appeared already well engaged with the issues at hand and in negotiating solutions.


SEBPOG's leading representative (Mic Healey) explained the situation with private owner border encroachment issues regarding the Palmer Ranch owned parcel, and how some SEBPOG members have luckily had the use of some buffer land - beyond the eastern termination of their backyard property lines and up to the barb wire fencing of the Palmer Ranch owned parcel for years - at the apparent benevolent tolerance and much appreciated generosity of the property owner. He went on to explain, that SEBPOG members freely acknowledged that there is no dispute as to were their actual eastern boundaries lay - as owners in SEBPOG are on recorded lots. Further he stated that the private encroachment issues had been previously explored for legal pursuit under adverse possession and or Florida's Boundary by Acquiescence law, however - he had decided not to advance any of these options at that time, nor wished to alienate his good working relationship with contacts at Palmer Ranch. In fact, SEBPOG's representative said, SEBPOG owners were very appreciative to the property owner - that they had been allowed to use a portion of the parcel, for the amount of time they have had (now over 20 years).

Unfortunately, Mr. Lobeck seemed to think these private encroachment issues between Palmer Ranch Holdings and SEBPOG members was some key leverage option for SEPOA... SEBPOG clearly states here that such issues are - private issues between themselves and Palmer Ranch, and will be settled as such without any need for SEPOA's interference or unsolicited legal counsel. These matters are of no concern to SEPOA, and will not be made "fodder" for litigating delaying tactics or other leverage against the advancement of the development. Since the ownership of the parcel in play is still currently with Palmer Ranch, the Taylor Morrison project will not be a factor in these simple encroachment issues being resolved well prior to conveyance of the land to the developer.

[ Following the meeting and in follow-up private engagements with SEPOA leadership, SEBPOG was shocked to learn that Mr. Lobeck, had not just simply been engaged by the board (at cost) - to speak at the meeting, but was rather already fully retained as the association's full compensated legal representative  "...thru the negotiations with TM and the County". ] ** (see update regarding this below)


At this point - SEBPOG felt the need to submit the following statement to SEPOA leadership.


SEBPOG / SEBPOG.ORG Statement to SEPOA of July 26th 2018

As per the ByLaws of Sorrento East Property Owners Association, Inc., Revised: November 4th, 2004, Article III (entitled) Purposes, Section A. (ref. below in Item B):

We, who are within the voluntary homeowners  organization known as: Sorrento East Property Owners Association, Inc. (a.k.a. SEPOA), and who,  are also currently -  “Full Active SEBPOG Members” (as defined within our documentation) of the group / informal organization known as: SEBPOG and or SEBPOG.ORG - put forth that any continued compensated legal counsel and or retention there of  - to be put forth, maintained, or proposed by SEPOA - in the specific matters of: “Buffer Zone Design” and or any and all private “Encroachment Issues”, existing or having existed between SEBPOG owners and Palmer Ranch Holding, Ltd. (McCann Holdings, Ltd.) - pertaining directly and or indirectly to: the new Taylor Morrison development planned for the parcel bordering the eastern properties in Sorrento East - is currently: NOT in our “mutual benefit” (see Item: A below) - as we have been exclusively engaged in this matter directly with the current property owner McCann Holdings, Ltd., Taylor Morrison and or their agents, and or Sarasota county local officials for several months.

Thus, we put forth that any such continuance of compensated unsolicited new intermediary legal assistance (in regards to the above said matters), works directly against our current open, productive, and highly beneficial working relationships with these contacts at this time of delicate negotiations.  As such - we will not support, accept, endorse, and nor will supply with information, and or contribute in any way, in any and all further compensated unwarranted unnecessary unwanted legal assistance or inquiries, brought forth by SEPOA and or their legal agents in the above matter as delineated.

It is our endorsed legal understanding of the current Association bylaws - as clearly written and referenced below - that no further legal involvement may be contracted, initiated, or maintained at this time, in the above specific matters - without our (SEBPOG’s) explicit and or expressed endorsement - to which we now emphatically withhold in the strongest terms.

Finally, should this, the above, prove insufficient, any SEBPOG members having remaining “encroachment issues” shall immediately voluntarily resigned from membership in Sorrento East Property Owners Association (SEPOA) for the duration of time as necessary, in which such action or compensated legal counsel is or pursued or contemplated by the board, and or its president and agents.  


Item A:

Ref: Legal Understanding of the term: mutual (i.e. - binding to both parties)adj., adv. referring to anything in which both parties have reciprocal rights, understanding or agreement.

Item B:

BYLAWS of SORRENTO EAST PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.

Revised: November 4th 2004

ARTICLE III  PURPOSES

The purposes for which this Association is organized are:

Maintain liaison with governmental and franchised activities to represent the interests of Sorrento East in matters relating to public services and utilities, environmental health and safety, zoning, etc., and to ensure continuing improvements for the mutual benefit of Association members.


Respectfully submitted to S.E.P.O.A. president: Bob Handley 07/26/18

** We have just concluded a new two hour update meeting with SEPOA's leadership and we feel - we are so blessed to have such a truly outstandingly intelligent and caring president as Mr. Bob Hanley , who is a gentleman and an excellent highly intelligent communicator! We are happy to announce we have a new refinement on the utilization of Mr. Lobeck's services by SEPOA:

"He will only be used as needed, and will be billing SEPOA hourly for services".

He will be instructed by SEPOA to "back off" initiating and or interfering with  any and all SEBPOG's private encroachment issues, and border property buffer design negotiations, now underway between SEBPOG & TM - as per the SEPOA president.

With the above in mind, and with no compromise in the above SEBPOG Statement, SEBPOG leadership is delighted to continue to work and communicate closely with SEPOA current's leadership, exclusively - towards the best independent mutually beneficial futures for both organization's members concerns.

Saturday, July 21, 2018

Who's Dan Lobeck & What He Has to Say...


The key speaker of the upcoming Sorrento East Property Owners Association (SEPOA) meeting on July 25th will be Mr. Dan Lobeck, Esq. - who will be addressing the raised concerns of some SEPOA members - relating to a large new planned development to be created by national home builder: Taylor Morrison. The proposed building parcel directly abuts the entire eastern border of the Sorrento East subdivision, on an approx. 100+ acre section, long owned by Palmer Ranch Holdings, Ltd. and would need to be rezoned from OUE-2 to RSF-2/PUD for the project to proceed.

SEBPOG believes Mr. Lobeck well understands the current realistic state of the pro building situation in Sarasota County, and the importance of the "Sarasota County Comprehensive Plan" (now inclusive of the Sarasota County Future Land Use Maps), and, the often additionally referenced: "Sarasota County 2050 Plan".   Mr. Lobeck's article in this Herald-Tribune of October 2016: County Plan ‘Update’ Betrays Us For Developers encapsulates the somber reality... and is one of the many reason SEBPOG chooses to work with the land owner, the developer Taylor Morrison and or their agents, and county officials on this project - for our members' well-being and continued preservation of property values.

Mr. Lobeck recently spoke in front of N.A.C.A. members last February, and pretty much reiterated the content of the above article.  You can watch and listen to his entire presentation below. (His speech begins on the video at the 1:14 mark):



Of note... in both the article above, and in the video, Mr. Lobeck appears to be a proponent of "Affordable Housing" - a somewhat politically correct term, which some may argue, should still be called: "Low Income Housing"... For SEBPOG members, having the choice between directly abutting a beautifully planned upscale community behind us (with an extensively designed buffer zone with a wall) - as is being built and clearly observable over at nearby Bellicina By Casey Key - or the worrisome specter of even the remotest future chance of a possible low income housing unit sprawl being plunked behind our homes; Umm,  thanks Mr. Lobeck - but we'll be choosing the former, rather than the latter... every time.

Friday, July 20, 2018

Message in a Baggie (w/Rock): SEPOA Meeting on New Proposed Development


Yesterday, some residents in Sorrento East were greeted by one of those "Message in a Baggie w/Rock" drops - that we often get from amateur cheapo contractors pedaling their wares and services... Alas - no such luck in this case, it was from an unknown sender, just click on the above image and you can read it for yourself...
We must comment, initially - that while we appreciate the efforts of the mystery sender... this message / baggie drop method can do more harm than good. A lot of our residents this time of year are gone to their Northern homes, and these things often just hang around on their driveways for days... indicating to possible thieves that the premises are currently unoccupied. (I.E. -  They're like a "Rob Me" flag for those paying attention.) Additionally, many people don't seem to even see them, not to mention the method is completely unprofessional... but, back to the contents.  

So, this is a notice about the special meeting (an official SEPOA meeting?) to be held at SEPOA's typical meeting location, the Lutheran Church across the street  from the plat: 7pm on 7/25/18. The topic of the special gathering - to discuss concerns of some residents, to the Sorrento at Palmer Ranch proposed Taylor Morrison development with the association's legal counsel: Dan Lobeck (of Lobeck & Hanson, P.A., Sarasota, FL).

The issues and concerns for the rezoning proposal are listed on the note... However, most of these questions were indeed addressed at the meeting of 06-12-18, lead by Taylor Morrison attorney: Mr. Charlie Bailey - but many folks were too busy shouting and talking amongst themselves to listen... (SEBPOG has a complete video of the meeting.) If you could not attend... you can read a summary of that rowdy gathering: here. Since this meeting, SEBPOG has had another 90 minute meeting with a multi-disciplinary team for the project (07-05-18), including again Mr. Bailey, agents from Taylor Morisson, and officials from Sarasota County Planning.

What follows are SEBPOG's thoughts and replies to the inquiries raised in the "Baggie Note":

"Increase in density of homes over current zoning."

This is true, the primary parcel is currently rated OUE-2 (1 house per two acres), which means about 50 homes on the parcel...


The new zoning request: RSF-2 / PUD is like Sorrento East... 3.5 homes per acre. This will allow from something like between 340 to 380 new homes, depending on access and a few other issues.

Unfortunately, the land has technically, already been "slated" for rezoning by the county. This was secured in the 2014 Sarasota County Future Land Use Guide map (which is part of the larger Comprehensive Plan document) - where it recommended flipping the property in the future into the applied for new zoning. Those not familiar with what the S.C. Future Land Use Guide is, need to research it... sadly, the time for input regarding the future of this parcel happened four years ago, when the updated S.C. Future Land Use Guide was crafted...

* The Sarasota County Future Land Use Guide Map was again updated in 2016. You may review it: here.

"Ingress/Egress" through Sorrento East"

The current developers plan calls for NO FULL ACCESS at North Rossetti, only an emergency access point. The other access for the new development is out on Route 681, so there will be NO INCREASE IN TRAFFIC.

"Increased Traffic"

There will be none - Please see above.

"Increase risk of safety (on roads) for pedestrians, cyclists, children, and wildlife"

Umm, nice try... again - there will be no increase, please see above.

"Rain/Storm water run-off and drainage increasing rish of flooding in Sorrento East"

Okay, this is one of SEBPOG's primary concerns, as is so stated in our Mission Statement (which you can review: here). In our extensive talks with the developer, and county planners, the project MUST be designed with massive and in depth hydrological concerns in mind.  The parcel must: (a.) continue to accept all run-off that currently feeds into the land, and (b.) shed no run-off, from the parcel, back into Sorrento East properties. The design of the border is key to these concerns, and it will contain swales (ditches), and passive grading, so the water is channeled properly. Again, this is a county mandate.

"Risks to the endangered wildlife living in Oscar Scherer State Park and also to wetland areas shared by Oscar Scherer and the parcel in question."

There is a rather large buffer that will be set up on the northern end of the parcel for wildlife concerns. Additionally, the small shared circular seasonal wetland is to be preserved and included in the design for the community.


SEBPOG hopes the above helps answer some of these concerns... It must be understood that ALL of these topics have been completely anticipated, and are being addressed by both county agencies and the developer. Thus, it is exceedingly doubtful any of these concerns will terminate or curtail the project - which is of a large financial nature and will most likely generate something close to two hundred million dollars in new real estate sales.

We in SEBPOG wish (like you) the project was not happening - that the land would be just left as a natural buffer, as it has been for many years. Unfortunately, we must be realistic and deal with the hand we have been dealt. We must make the best of it.  The reality is: this parcel is indeed private property - it is owned by one of the most well known large land owners in the county with deep roots within the community. The company has tried to develop it several times over the past twenty or so years, and it is quite unrealistic to think - they would leave it alone, even if this developer (who has shown an impressive and sincere effort - to work with directly affected Sorrento East property owners) should somehow fail or be denied re-zoning.

With the above in mind... if non-abutting SE residents really desire to help their fellow Sorrento East neighbors - the border property owners, who will be unfortunately saddled with this... and will be on the "front lines" of this project - directly enduring the upsetness, noise, and dirt - for years... please take the time to frequently visit SEBPOG.ORG and read it... or speak with those in Sepbog who are well versed and up to date - on the details of this endeavor, as it moves forward. (We have been hard at work on this thing since late in 2017.)

Again, while we sincerely appreciate the effort of SEPOA members... please recognize that an ineffective and combative campaign raised by non-abutting / non-directly affected SEPOA members - will only run counter productive to SEBPOG's current excellent working relationships with the land owner, project developer and their agents, and county planning officials assigned to the development. (In essense, you could hurt us - not help.) There is much to be said for the age old expression: "Sometimes you get more with a carrot, than you do with a stick."  Please rest assured - we at SEBPOG are on top of this and doing our very best... Thank you for reading.